The Legal And Ethical Issues Involving Physician Assisted...

As of January 2015 there are five states in the U.S. that have declared the Death with Dignity Act a constitutional right for a competent, terminally ill patient. Under what conditions is physician assisted suicide morally acceptable, is the question at hand and did these states make the right decision on such a slippery slope debate. This paper will go on to explain one side of this very touchy debate, it will also consider objections from the other side, and ultimately defend the position physician assisted suicide is wrong not only morally but also, ethically. My argument for this thesis is provided below: P1: Physician assisted suicide violates the doctor’s Hippocratic Oath. P2: It demeans the value of human life. P3: The unneeded pressure on physicians to recommend assisted suicide. P4: The many legal and ethical issues involving physician assisted suicide C: Therefore, physician assisted suicide is wrong, morally and ethically This argument is inductive, becasue the premises provide strong support for the conclusion. A strong argument shows that the conclusion is highly likely to be true given the truth of the premises. The support that I have given for the argument in the premises below examine the truth and logical explanations of the conclusion that I have stated. The first premise states that physician assisted suicide violates the doctor’s Hippocratic Oath. What is the Hippocratic Oath? What I mean by violate is that they fail to comply with a rule orShow MoreRelatedPhysician Assisted Suicide : Controversial Healthcare And Political Realms Alike1218 Words   |  5 Pages Physician-Assisted Suicide Elissa Munoz-Tucker University of Arizona Abstract Physician-assisted suicide is controversial in healthcare and political realms alike. Currently, this end-of-life option is practiced in five states within the United States. Social concerns regarding assisted suicide revolve around ethical quandaries; providing the means to a patient’s death is contradictory to ethical principles of healthcare providers. Political concerns surroundingRead MoreEuthanasia And Physician Assisted Suicide1629 Words   |  7 Pagesillnesses or major health problems, assisted suicide creates options to reduce the amount of suffering the patient must enduring. Dying with dignity could be beneficial for not only the person who is dying, but also the person’s family and loved ones. This option, however, is often viewed as unethical and immoral throughout society. Physician-assisted suicide offers an option for those with health issues but poses various ethical and social issues. Assisted death is practiced in two differentRead MoreAssisted Suicide And The Euthanasia Movement1273 Words   |  6 PagesAssisted Suicide Imagine being in enough excruciating pain for a long enough time and deciding that even dying would be better. Assisted suicide is affecting more people around the world every day; either under agreeable or disagreeable terms, depending on each person’s opinion. What is assisted suicide and why is controversy over this topic still here after at least 1,500 years of existence (A Merciful End: The Euthanasia Movement in Modern America)? There are many factors to consider whenRead MoreThe Death Of The Medical Field Essay1598 Words   |  7 Pagesand purposefully simulating the condition of one who is dead, based on higher brain functioning † (Soh 221). Legalization of suicide in the medical field is a complicated topic involving legal and ethical backgrounds, decisions within the state of the patient and their physician of care must be closely examined. Assisted suicide, to be exact, is the act when the physician provides medication or a prescription to a patient at h is or her explicit request with the understanding that the patient intendsRead MoreMedical, Social And Ethical Reasons Essay1537 Words   |  7 PagesSince the development of medicine, people have requested doctors to end suffering through physician assisted suicide (PAS) (Boudreau 1). PAS refers to the practice in which physicians knowingly provide an individual with the means and/or knowledge to commit suicide, which includes counselling about medication and prescribing or supplying such drugs (Pereira 1). In my opinion, terminally ill patients should be allowed to end their lives through PAS because it affords the patients the choice of whetherRead MoreEuthanasi Assisted Suicide And Euthanasia Essay2335 Words   |  10 PagesPhysician- Assisted Suicide Framing the Issue Many legal, ethical and personal issues and dilemmas have been identified in relation to physician- assisted suicide and euthanasia. Issues such as whether physician- assisted suicide or euthanasia is ethically acceptable, or what criterion is legally and socially necessary to determine whether a person can receive assisted suicide measures to end ones life. A variety of literature reviews have been created to address this topic and generate knowledgeRead MoreAssisted Death And Voluntary Euthanasia1586 Words   |  7 Pages SHOULD THE LAW BE REFORMED TO ALLOW ‘ASSISTED DYING’ FOR THE TERMINALLY ILL? To begin with, assisted dying remains highly topical and debated, both in the public and medical arena. Assisted death, incorporates both physician assisted suicide and voluntary euthanasia. It gives the freedom to a terminally ill person or a mentally competent adult, to choose on their own free will and after meeting strict legal safeguards, takes prescribed medication which will end their life in dying. There are twoRead MoreEthical, Moral and Religious Issues Surrounding Euthanasia Essay1214 Words   |  5 Pagesmercy. In contrast to euthanasia, the definition of assisted suicide is suicide committed by someone with assistance from another person. Although the distinction between the two is subtle, the end result is the same- death. When discussing physician-assisted suicide (hereafter referred to as PAS), both terms are used interchangeably. The public and medical community remain deeply divided on this issue, citing moral, ethical, or legal issues. Advocates state that the ter minally ill who are deemedRead MoreEssay on Physician-Assisted Suicide1782 Words   |  8 PagesSuicide is one person’s personal decision; physician-assisted suicide is a patient who is not capable of carrying the task out themselves asking a physician for access to lethal medication. What people may fail to see however is that the physician is not the only healthcare personnel involved; it may include, but is not limited to, a physician, nurse, and pharmacist. This may conflict with the healthcare worker’s own morals and there are cases in which the patient suffers from depression, or theRead MoreThe Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms1715 Words   |  7 PagesAs such, this paper will examine a legal case that exemplifies the changing societal beliefs, and will analyze the specifics of the law, paying close attention to the nature of the legal conflict, policy implications, and its contribution to the understanding of Canadian law. In the landmark case of dealing with assisted suicide in Canada, Carter v. Canada (Attorney General) , the Supreme Court of Canada (hereafter SCC) revisited the issue of assisted suicide and confirmed that Canadians have the